352-001 · Question #241
You work for a financial institution that is planning to deploy a new multicast application in your network to do real-time trading. This application will be run simultaneously by thousands of…
The correct answer is D. PIM Bidirectional. PIM Bidirectional (Bidir-PIM) is optimal for many-to-many multicast with thousands of sources because it maintains only shared (*,G) tree state and never creates per-source (S,G) entries.
Question
You work for a financial institution that is planning to deploy a new multicast application in your network to do real-time trading. This application will be run simultaneously by thousands of traders located throughout your network, each a source of several IP multicast streams, to carry the "sell" and "buy" trading bids. All routers in your network have full hardware support for all PIM multicast modes. Which mode should you use in order to minimize the impact of the new application on the routers in your network?
Options
- APIM Any-Source Multicast
- BPIM Dense Mode
- CPIM Source Specific Multicast
- DPIM Bidirectional
How the community answered
(39 responses)- A5% (2)
- B8% (3)
- C18% (7)
- D69% (27)
Why each option
PIM Bidirectional (Bidir-PIM) is optimal for many-to-many multicast with thousands of sources because it maintains only shared (*,G) tree state and never creates per-source (S,G) entries.
PIM Any-Source Multicast (ASM/PIM-SM) can switch from the shared (*,G) tree to a per-source (S,G) shortest-path tree, creating thousands of (S,G) state entries on routers when thousands of active sources are present.
PIM Dense Mode floods multicast traffic throughout the entire network and then uses prune messages to stop unwanted flows; with thousands of sources this produces a massive flood-and-prune storm that severely burdens all routers.
PIM Source Specific Multicast (SSM) always uses source-specific (S,G) trees and requires receivers to know each source address in advance, which is impractical with thousands of dynamic sources and creates per-source state for each one.
Bidir-PIM builds a single bidirectional shared tree per group rooted at the RP and never creates (S,G) source-tree state, so routers hold only (*,G) entries regardless of how many sources exist. With thousands of simultaneous sources, this dramatically reduces multicast forwarding state on every router compared to any mode that builds per-source state, minimizing CPU and memory impact across the network.
Concept tested: PIM Bidirectional shared-tree scalability for many-to-many multicast
Source: https://www.cisco.com/c/en/us/td/docs/ios-xml/ios/ipmulti_pim/configuration/xe-16/imc-pim-xe-16-book/imc-bidir-pim.html
Topics
Community Discussion
No community discussion yet for this question.