PHR · Question #29
Lucas has asked his manager to take time off from work because of a holiday his religion celebrates. Fran agrees but tells Lucas that he will be inspecting his project work to ensure that the work is
The correct answer is D. Disparate treatment. Disparate treatment occurs when an employer treats an employee differently than similarly situated employees because of a protected characteristic. Here, the manager singles out Lucas for extra work scrutiny specifically because of his religious accommodation request.
Question
Lucas has asked his manager to take time off from work because of a holiday his religion celebrates. Fran agrees but tells Lucas that he will be inspecting his project work to ensure that the work is accurate and not suffering because of the requested time off. This is an example of what?
Options
- APerpetuating past discrimination
- BReligious persecution in the workforce
- CQuality control
- DDisparate treatment
How the community answered
(37 responses)- A5% (2)
- B3% (1)
- C14% (5)
- D78% (29)
Why each option
Disparate treatment occurs when an employer treats an employee differently than similarly situated employees because of a protected characteristic. Here, the manager singles out Lucas for extra work scrutiny specifically because of his religious accommodation request.
Perpetuating past discrimination refers to continuing historical systemic bias patterns across a workforce, not a manager's targeted differential treatment of one employee for requesting a religious accommodation.
Religious persecution implies severe or systematic oppression of religious belief broadly; the precise legal and HR classification for this type of employment-specific unequal treatment is disparate treatment.
Quality control is a legitimate, uniformly applied business process; here the heightened inspection is triggered solely by the religious accommodation request rather than standard operational procedure, making it discriminatory in nature.
Disparate treatment is the legal term for treating an individual differently than other employees because of a protected characteristic such as religion. By agreeing to the time off but imposing additional work inspections not applied to other employees, Fran is subjecting Lucas to different terms and conditions of employment based on his religious practice - a direct violation of Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964.
Concept tested: Disparate treatment based on religious accommodation
Source: https://www.eeoc.gov/prohibited-employment-policiespractices
Topics
Community Discussion
No community discussion yet for this question.