CBAP · Question #376
A business analyst (BA) facilitated elicitation activities with subject matter experts and end users using observation, workshops, and interviews. After comparing the results, how should the BA resolv
The correct answer is B. Set up additional activities to collaboratively resolve the issues. When elicitation results vary across techniques, the BA should facilitate additional collaborative sessions to surface and resolve the root causes of discrepancies.
Question
A business analyst (BA) facilitated elicitation activities with subject matter experts and end users using observation, workshops, and interviews. After comparing the results, how should the BA resolve the variations?
Options
- AIdentify a few key stakeholders to resolve the conflicts
- BSet up additional activities to collaboratively resolve the issues
- CRemove requirements that cause differences
- DWeight the results from the observation because it is more reliable
How the community answered
(36 responses)- A14% (5)
- B78% (28)
- C6% (2)
- D3% (1)
Why each option
When elicitation results vary across techniques, the BA should facilitate additional collaborative sessions to surface and resolve the root causes of discrepancies.
Limiting conflict resolution to a few key stakeholders excludes subject matter experts and end users whose input created the variation, risking an incomplete or biased resolution.
Setting up additional collaborative activities allows all relevant stakeholders to examine conflicting information together and reach consensus through structured dialogue. This aligns with BABOK guidance that elicitation and confirmation are iterative processes used to resolve discrepancies. Collaborative resolution ensures no valid perspective is dismissed and that the final requirements reflect an agreed-upon understanding.
Removing requirements that cause differences discards potentially valid business needs without first understanding whether they reflect legitimate requirements.
Weighting observation as inherently more reliable is a subjective bias - no single elicitation technique is universally superior, as each captures different aspects of requirements.
Concept tested: Resolving elicitation result variations collaboratively
Source: https://www.iiba.org/career-resources/a-business-analysis-body-of-knowledge/babok/
Topics
Community Discussion
No community discussion yet for this question.