220-801 · Question #835
A user reports that their hard drive has failed and needs to be replaced. Which of the following should the technician do FIRST?
The correct answer is D. Ask the user diagnostic questions. Before taking any physical action on a reported hard drive failure, the technician must first ask the user diagnostic questions to identify and confirm the problem, following the first step of the CompTIA troubleshooting methodology.
Question
A user reports that their hard drive has failed and needs to be replaced. Which of the following should the technician do FIRST?
Options
- ARun the hard disk manufacturer's diagnostic program
- BRe-image the drive
- CReplace the hard drive and load Windows
- DAsk the user diagnostic questions
How the community answered
(51 responses)- A6% (3)
- B4% (2)
- C2% (1)
- D88% (45)
Why each option
Before taking any physical action on a reported hard drive failure, the technician must first ask the user diagnostic questions to identify and confirm the problem, following the first step of the CompTIA troubleshooting methodology.
Running a manufacturer's diagnostic tool is a verification step that comes after gathering information about the problem, not before.
Re-imaging is a corrective action that assumes the drive is functional and the problem is confirmed, not a first troubleshooting step.
Replacing the hard drive is a physical repair action that should only occur after the problem is properly identified and confirmed.
Asking diagnostic questions is the first step in the CompTIA A+ troubleshooting methodology - 'identify the problem.' This helps confirm whether the drive truly failed, understand what symptoms occurred, and gather information before any physical or corrective action is taken. Skipping this step risks unnecessary hardware replacement or data loss.
Concept tested: CompTIA troubleshooting methodology - identify the problem first
Source: https://www.comptia.org/blog/troubleshooting-methodology
Topics
Community Discussion
No community discussion yet for this question.