nerdexam
GIAC

GSEC · Question #133

Why are false positives such a problem with IPS technology?

The correct answer is D. Rules are often misinterpreted. False positives in IPS occur when detection rules incorrectly classify legitimate traffic as malicious, and the core problem is that those rules are inherently difficult to write precisely for all traffic patterns.

Network Security

Question

Why are false positives such a problem with IPS technology?

Options

  • AFile integrity is not guaranteed.
  • BMalicious code can get into the network.
  • CLegitimate services are not delivered.
  • DRules are often misinterpreted.

How the community answered

(20 responses)
  • B
    5% (1)
  • C
    10% (2)
  • D
    85% (17)

Why each option

False positives in IPS occur when detection rules incorrectly classify legitimate traffic as malicious, and the core problem is that those rules are inherently difficult to write precisely for all traffic patterns.

AFile integrity is not guaranteed.

File integrity monitoring is a separate security control unrelated to IPS rule-based traffic inspection and false positive generation.

BMalicious code can get into the network.

Malicious code bypassing detection describes a false negative, which is the opposite problem from a false positive.

CLegitimate services are not delivered.

Legitimate services being disrupted is the downstream consequence of false positives, not the technical reason why false positives occur within IPS rule evaluation.

DRules are often misinterpreted.Correct

IPS systems depend on rule sets to distinguish malicious from legitimate traffic, but these rules are complex and can be imprecise or overly broad, causing the engine to misinterpret normal traffic as an attack. This misinterpretation is the root technical reason false positives are a persistent problem - the rules themselves cannot perfectly model every legitimate traffic pattern. As a result, valid sessions are incorrectly blocked whenever the engine applies a rule to traffic it was not designed to match.

Concept tested: IPS false positive causes from imprecise rule sets

Source: https://www.cisco.com/c/en/us/td/docs/security/ips/7-0/configuration/guide/idm/idmg70/idm_sigover.html

Topics

#IPS#false positives#signature rules#intrusion prevention

Community Discussion

No community discussion yet for this question.

Full GSEC Practice