CRISC · Question #79
Which of the following should be of GREATEST concern when reviewing the results of an independent control assessment to determine the effectiveness of a vendor's control environment?
The correct answer is A. The report was provided directly from the vendor. The greatest concern when reviewing an independent control assessment for a vendor's control environment is if the report was provided directly from the vendor.
Question
Which of the following should be of GREATEST concern when reviewing the results of an independent control assessment to determine the effectiveness of a vendor's control environment?
Options
- AThe report was provided directly from the vendor.
- BThe risk associated with multiple control gaps was accepted.
- CThe control owners disagreed with the auditor's recommendations.
- DThe controls had recurring noncompliance.
How the community answered
(23 responses)- A52% (12)
- B17% (4)
- C26% (6)
- D4% (1)
Why each option
The greatest concern when reviewing an independent control assessment for a vendor's control environment is if the report was provided directly from the vendor.
The greatest concern is that the report was provided directly from the vendor because it introduces a potential conflict of interest and raises questions about the independence and objectivity of the assessment. While the assessment itself might be performed by an independent third party, the vendor acting as the intermediary could potentially withhold or modify information, compromising the reliability of the findings.
Accepted multiple control gaps, while concerning, indicates a known risk acceptance, which is a formal decision, rather than a lack of objectivity in reporting.
Control owners disagreeing with recommendations is a common audit finding and management challenge, not an immediate red flag about the report's independence.
Recurring noncompliance indicates control weaknesses but doesn't inherently invalidate the independence or veracity of the report itself.
Concept tested: Vendor control assessment independence
Source: https://us.aicpa.org/content/dam/aicpa/interestareas/frc/assuranceadvisoryservices/downloadabledocuments/soc-reports-an-introductory-overview.pdf
Topics
Community Discussion
No community discussion yet for this question.