CRISC · Question #626
External penetration tests MUST include:
The correct answer is D. advance approval from system owners. Any form of penetration testing, especially external, absolutely requires advance approval from system owners and legal teams to ensure it is authorized and understood to be a controlled attack, not a malicious one.
Question
External penetration tests MUST include:
Options
- Ause of consultants to ensure completeness.
- Bcommunications to users of the target systems.
- Cchanges to target data to prove the attack was successful.
- Dadvance approval from system owners.
How the community answered
(35 responses)- A3% (1)
- B6% (2)
- C3% (1)
- D89% (31)
Why each option
Any form of penetration testing, especially external, absolutely requires advance approval from system owners and legal teams to ensure it is authorized and understood to be a controlled attack, not a malicious one.
While consultants are often used for penetration tests due to specialized expertise, their use is not a mandatory component for all external penetration tests.
Communicating to end-users is typically avoided in a 'black box' or 'double-blind' test to simulate a real-world scenario more accurately, though it might occur in other testing types.
Penetration tests should generally aim to identify vulnerabilities and exploit them without causing damage, and *modifying* production data is usually explicitly out of scope unless specifically authorized in a test environment.
Penetration tests simulate real attacks and can impact systems, so obtaining explicit, documented advance approval from system owners, business unit leads, and legal counsel is a fundamental ethical and legal requirement before any testing begins. This ensures all parties are aware of the scope, potential impact, and authorization for the activity.
Concept tested: Penetration testing prerequisites
Source: https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/compliance/regulatory/offering-pen-testing
Topics
Community Discussion
No community discussion yet for this question.