CRISC · Question #397
An assessment of information security controls has identified ineffective controls. Which of the following should be the risk practitioner's FIRST course of action?
The correct answer is A. Determine whether the impact is outside the risk appetite. When ineffective information security controls are identified, the risk practitioner's first action should be to determine if the resulting impact falls outside the organization's risk appetite.
Question
An assessment of information security controls has identified ineffective controls. Which of the following should be the risk practitioner's FIRST course of action?
Options
- ADetermine whether the impact is outside the risk appetite.
- BRequest a formal acceptance of risk from senior management.
- CReport the ineffective control for inclusion in the next audit report.
- DDeploy a compensating control to address the identified deficiencies.
How the community answered
(48 responses)- A79% (38)
- B13% (6)
- C2% (1)
- D6% (3)
Why each option
When ineffective information security controls are identified, the risk practitioner's first action should be to determine if the resulting impact falls outside the organization's risk appetite.
Upon identifying ineffective controls, the immediate concern is to understand the potential exposure to the organization. Determining whether the resulting impact falls outside the established risk appetite is the critical first step because it quantifies the severity of the issue and dictates the urgency and type of subsequent actions required, such as remediation or formal risk acceptance.
Requesting formal risk acceptance is premature without first determining if the impact of the ineffective control actually exceeds the risk appetite and thus requires senior management's explicit acceptance.
Reporting for the next audit report is a reactive and potentially delayed action; the immediate priority is to assess the current risk posed by the ineffective control.
Deploying a compensating control is a potential remediation *action*, but it should follow an assessment of the risk's severity and whether it exceeds appetite, not precede it.
Concept tested: Risk assessment after control failure
Topics
Community Discussion
No community discussion yet for this question.