CAS-001 · Question #500
A government agency considers confidentiality to be of utmost importance and availability issues to be of least importance. Knowing this, which of the following correctly orders various…
The correct answer is A. Insecure direct object references, CSRF, Smurf. This question tests the ability to rank security vulnerabilities from most critical to least critical for an organization that prioritizes confidentiality above integrity and treats availability as least important.
Question
A government agency considers confidentiality to be of utmost importance and availability issues to be of least importance. Knowing this, which of the following correctly orders various vulnerabilities in the order of MOST important to LEAST important?
Options
- AInsecure direct object references, CSRF, Smurf
- BPrivilege escalation, Application DoS, Buffer overflow
- CSQL injection, Resource exhaustion, Privilege escalation
- DCSRF, Fault injection, Memory leaks
How the community answered
(52 responses)- A46% (24)
- B10% (5)
- C17% (9)
- D27% (14)
Why each option
This question tests the ability to rank security vulnerabilities from most critical to least critical for an organization that prioritizes confidentiality above integrity and treats availability as least important.
Insecure direct object references are a confidentiality vulnerability - they allow attackers to directly access unauthorized data objects, which is the agency's highest priority concern. CSRF is primarily an integrity attack that coerces authenticated users into performing unintended state-changing actions, placing it correctly in the middle tier. Smurf is a distributed reflection-based DoS attack targeting availability, which the agency ranks as least important, making this sequence the only option that correctly maps confidentiality-integrity-availability to high-medium-low priority.
This option places Application DoS, a pure availability attack, ahead of Buffer overflow, which can enable arbitrary code execution and confidentiality breaches, incorrectly elevating an availability threat above a confidentiality one.
This option ranks Privilege escalation last despite it being a high-severity confidentiality and integrity threat, while Resource exhaustion, an availability concern, is ranked in the middle - reversing the correct priority order.
None of the three vulnerabilities listed - CSRF, Fault injection, and Memory leaks - represent a primary confidentiality threat at the top of the ranking, so no ordering of this set correctly reflects a confidentiality-first model.
Concept tested: Ranking vulnerabilities by CIA triad priority under confidentiality-first model
Source: https://owasp.org/www-project-top-ten/
Topics
Community Discussion
No community discussion yet for this question.