400-007 · Question #266
Company XYZ connects its sites over a private WAN. Their overlay network is running a DMVPN setup where the headquarters site is the hub. The company is planning on implementing multicast routing on…
The correct answer is D. PIM sparse mode with RP located at the hub. In a DMVPN hub-and-spoke overlay, PIM Sparse Mode with the Rendezvous Point at the hub is the correct multicast design because it avoids unnecessary flooding across the WAN and centralizes multicast distribution at the natural aggregation point.
Question
Company XYZ connects its sites over a private WAN. Their overlay network is running a DMVPN setup where the headquarters site is the hub. The company is planning on implementing multicast routing on the network. What should be used in the multicast routing design?
Options
- APIM dense mode with RP located at the hub
- BPIM sparse mode with RP located at each remote site
- CPIM dense mode with RP located at each remote site
- DPIM sparse mode with RP located at the hub
How the community answered
(44 responses)- A23% (10)
- B5% (2)
- C11% (5)
- D61% (27)
Why each option
In a DMVPN hub-and-spoke overlay, PIM Sparse Mode with the Rendezvous Point at the hub is the correct multicast design because it avoids unnecessary flooding across the WAN and centralizes multicast distribution at the natural aggregation point.
PIM Dense Mode uses a flood-and-prune mechanism that initially sends multicast traffic to all routers, which is highly inefficient over a WAN and can cause bandwidth saturation on DMVPN tunnels.
Placing the RP at each remote spoke site creates a fragmented RP design that does not scale and introduces complex RP reachability requirements between spokes in a DMVPN environment.
PIM Dense Mode is unsuitable for WAN environments regardless of RP placement because its flooding behavior wastes limited WAN bandwidth on DMVPN tunnel interfaces.
PIM Sparse Mode is appropriate for WAN overlays like DMVPN because it uses an explicit join model, sending multicast traffic only to routers that have requested it, which preserves WAN bandwidth. Placing the RP at the hub is the correct choice because the hub is the central spoke aggregation point in a DMVPN topology, allowing spokes to register sources and join groups through a single, reachable RP without requiring spoke-to-spoke RP reachability.
Concept tested: DMVPN multicast design with PIM sparse mode RP placement
Source: https://www.cisco.com/c/en/us/td/docs/ios-xml/ios/ipmulti_pim/configuration/xe-16/imc-pim-xe-16-book/imc-pim-sparse-mode.html
Topics
Community Discussion
No community discussion yet for this question.