SK0-004 · Question #726
A rack contains 20 1U servers with dual power supplies and two PDUs on separate 15A circuits. Each server is connected to both PDUs, and each server draws 1A of current in normal operation. One of…
The correct answer is C. All of the servers will lose power immediately because both circuit breakers will switch off. When one 15A circuit trips, the full 20A server load transfers to the remaining 15A circuit, exceeding its rating and tripping the second breaker, cutting power to all servers.
Question
A rack contains 20 1U servers with dual power supplies and two PDUs on separate 15A circuits. Each server is connected to both PDUs, and each server draws 1A of current in normal operation. One of the circuit breakers switches off due to a power surge. Which of the following will happen NEXT?
Options
- AThe servers will continue to operate normally due to their redundant power sources.
- BThe servers will shut down gracefully when power is lost on one of the two circuits.
- CAll of the servers will lose power immediately because both circuit breakers will switch off.
- DHalf of the servers will lose power, but the others will continue operating on the good circuit.
How the community answered
(34 responses)- A12% (4)
- B6% (2)
- C65% (22)
- D18% (6)
Why each option
When one 15A circuit trips, the full 20A server load transfers to the remaining 15A circuit, exceeding its rating and tripping the second breaker, cutting power to all servers.
Dual power supplies provide per-server redundancy against a single PSU failure, but cannot prevent the second circuit breaker from tripping when the total transferred load of 20A exceeds its 15A rated capacity.
Servers do not gracefully shut down in this scenario - the second circuit breaker trips instantly due to overload, resulting in immediate ungraceful power loss rather than a controlled shutdown sequence.
With 20 servers each drawing 1A, total load is 20A spread across two 15A circuits (approximately 10A each under normal operation). When one breaker trips due to a power surge, all 20A of load attempts to draw from the single remaining 15A circuit. This immediately exceeds the 15A breaker rating, tripping the second breaker and removing power from all servers simultaneously.
Half the servers losing power would only occur if each server had a single PSU connected to only one PDU; since every server has dual PSUs connected to both PDUs, the entire 20A load shifts to the surviving circuit and overloads it.
Concept tested: Power circuit capacity and redundant PDU failover calculation
Source: https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/azure/well-architected/reliability/redundancy
Topics
Community Discussion
No community discussion yet for this question.