ICYB · Question #141
A process has a high number of defects. Before performing root-cause analysis, the team should first:
The correct answer is B. Validate the measurement system. Before trusting the data that shows a high defect count, you must confirm that the measurement system itself is accurate and reliable - this is called Measurement System Analysis (MSA) or a Gauge R&R study. If the measurement system has significant variation or bias, the "high de
Question
A process has a high number of defects. Before performing root-cause analysis, the team should first:
Options
- AImprove the process immediately
- BValidate the measurement system
- CRun a capability study
- DCreate a control plan
How the community answered
(44 responses)- A7% (3)
- B80% (35)
- C11% (5)
- D2% (1)
Explanation
Before trusting the data that shows a high defect count, you must confirm that the measurement system itself is accurate and reliable - this is called Measurement System Analysis (MSA) or a Gauge R&R study. If the measurement system has significant variation or bias, the "high defects" may be a measurement artifact rather than a real process problem, making any root-cause analysis built on that data worthless.
Why the distractors are wrong:
- A (Improve the process immediately): Acting before understanding the root cause is reactive and wastes resources - you may "fix" the wrong thing entirely.
- C (Run a capability study): Capability studies are meaningful only after you've confirmed your measurements are valid; a Cpk calculated from bad measurements is meaningless.
- D (Create a control plan): Control plans come at the end of an improvement cycle (Control phase in DMAIC), not at the start of investigation.
Memory tip: Think "Measure before you manage." In DMAIC, the Measure phase validates the measurement system before Analyze (root cause) begins. When you see "before root-cause analysis," your mind should jump to the Measure phase - and MSA lives there.
Topics
Community Discussion
No community discussion yet for this question.