nerdexam
GIAC

GSEC · Question #289

What security advantage does the utilization of a switch as opposed to a hub offer for a secure network design?

The correct answer is B. A switch will make it more difficult for an attacker that may control a compromised system to be. Switches forward frames only to the intended destination port using MAC address tables, preventing other hosts on the segment from passively intercepting traffic.

Networking and Core Concepts

Question

What security advantage does the utilization of a switch as opposed to a hub offer for a secure network design?

Options

  • AA switch will make it possible to provide a physical separation of the cables used to connect
  • BA switch will make it more difficult for an attacker that may control a compromised system to be
  • CA switch will make it easier to deploy Intrusion detection or intrusion prevention systems as a
  • DA switch will remove the need for utilization of a host-based firewall.

How the community answered

(45 responses)
  • A
    4% (2)
  • B
    78% (35)
  • C
    16% (7)
  • D
    2% (1)

Why each option

Switches forward frames only to the intended destination port using MAC address tables, preventing other hosts on the segment from passively intercepting traffic.

AA switch will make it possible to provide a physical separation of the cables used to connect

Physical cable separation is a physical security measure unrelated to the logical per-port traffic isolation that switches provide compared to hubs.

BA switch will make it more difficult for an attacker that may control a compromised system to beCorrect

Unlike hubs, which broadcast every frame to all connected ports, switches maintain MAC address tables and deliver frames only to the port of the intended recipient. This means a compromised system on a switched network cannot passively sniff traffic destined for other hosts, significantly reducing the risk of credential theft and data interception via promiscuous-mode packet capture.

CA switch will make it easier to deploy Intrusion detection or intrusion prevention systems as a

IDS/IPS deployment complexity is not determined by switch versus hub topology; both environments require port mirroring (SPAN) or inline taps to capture traffic for inspection.

DA switch will remove the need for utilization of a host-based firewall.

Switches operate at Layer 2 and have no bearing on host-based firewalls, which protect individual systems from unauthorized connections independently of the underlying network device type.

Concept tested: Switch vs hub traffic isolation and sniffing prevention

Source: https://www.cisco.com/c/en/us/products/switches/what-is-a-network-switch.html

Topics

#network switch#hub#traffic isolation#sniffing prevention

Community Discussion

No community discussion yet for this question.

Full GSEC Practice