GSEC · Question #255
A Network Engineer is charged with maintaining and protecting a network with a high availability requirement. In addition to other defenses, they have chosen to implement a NIPS. How should the NIPS…
The correct answer is D. Fail-open. A NIPS in front of a firewall should be configured to fail-open so that a device failure does not disrupt network availability, with the firewall still acting as a security backstop.
Question
A Network Engineer is charged with maintaining and protecting a network with a high availability requirement. In addition to other defenses, they have chosen to implement a NIPS. How should the NIPS failure conditions be configured to ensure availability if the NIPS is installed in front of the Firewall that protects the DMZ?
Options
- AFail safe
- BFail smart
- CFail-closed
- DFail-open
How the community answered
(58 responses)- A10% (6)
- B3% (2)
- C7% (4)
- D79% (46)
Why each option
A NIPS in front of a firewall should be configured to fail-open so that a device failure does not disrupt network availability, with the firewall still acting as a security backstop.
Fail-safe in an IPS context typically means fail-closed, which blocks all traffic on failure and directly violates the high-availability requirement.
Fail-smart is not a recognized standard IPS failure mode and therefore cannot be configured as an explicit device behavior.
Fail-closed causes the NIPS to block all traffic upon failure, which maximizes security but directly conflicts with the stated high-availability requirement.
Fail-open means that when the NIPS becomes unavailable, traffic is permitted to pass without inspection rather than being blocked. Because the NIPS sits in front of the firewall - which remains operational - the firewall continues to enforce access controls even during a NIPS failure. This preserves the high-availability requirement while retaining a secondary layer of protection downstream.
Concept tested: NIPS failure mode configuration for high availability
Source: https://csrc.nist.gov/publications/detail/sp/800-94/final
Topics
Community Discussion
No community discussion yet for this question.