CAS-003 · Question #830
The HVAC and fire suppression systems that were recently deployed at multiple locations are susceptible to a new vulnerability. A security engineer needs to ensure the vulnerability is not…
The correct answer is C. Create a segmented subnet for all HVAC devices and the smart controller. Before applying detection signatures or access controls, the correct first step for protecting vulnerable OT/IoT devices is to isolate them through network segmentation, limiting the attack surface before any other mitigation is layered on.
Question
The HVAC and fire suppression systems that were recently deployed at multiple locations are susceptible to a new vulnerability. A security engineer needs to ensure the vulnerability is not exploited. The devices are directly managed by a smart controller and do not need access to other parts of the network. Signatures are available to detect this vulnerability. Which of the following should be the FIRST step in completing the request?
Options
- ADeploy a NAC solution that disables devices with unknown MACs.
- BCreate a firewall policy with access to the smart controller from the internal network only.
- CCreate a segmented subnet for all HVAC devices and the smart controller.
- DCreate an IPS profile for the HVAC devices that includes the signatures.
How the community answered
(29 responses)- A17% (5)
- B10% (3)
- C45% (13)
- D28% (8)
Why each option
Before applying detection signatures or access controls, the correct first step for protecting vulnerable OT/IoT devices is to isolate them through network segmentation, limiting the attack surface before any other mitigation is layered on.
NAC based on MAC address filtering is easily bypassed by MAC spoofing and does not address the vulnerability itself or isolate the devices from one another or from the broader network.
A firewall policy restricting access to the smart controller from the internal network only is a valid follow-on control, but without segmentation first, it does not prevent lateral communication between the HVAC devices and other internal hosts.
Creating a segmented subnet for the HVAC devices and their smart controller enforces isolation at the network level, ensuring that even if the vulnerability is exploited, lateral movement to the broader network is prevented. Segmentation is the foundational control from which all other mitigations (IPS, firewall rules, NAC) are then applied with clearly defined scope, and it directly satisfies the requirement that devices do not need access to other parts of the network.
Deploying an IPS profile with the available signatures is an important second step, but it can only be scoped and applied effectively after the devices are isolated in a defined network segment.
Concept tested: OT/IoT network segmentation as primary vulnerability mitigation
Source: https://www.cisa.gov/sites/default/files/publications/NIST.SP.800-82r2.pdf
Topics
Community Discussion
No community discussion yet for this question.