352-001 · Question #657
What is the advantage of using a router instead of a switch when implementing Hierarchical VPLS (H- VPLS) CE devices?
The correct answer is A. MAC addresses on the entire broadcast domain are hidden from PEs, allowing for batter. Using a router as the CE device in H-VPLS causes all customer MAC addresses to be hidden behind the router's single MAC address, preventing MAC table exhaustion on provider edge devices.
Question
What is the advantage of using a router instead of a switch when implementing Hierarchical VPLS (H- VPLS) CE devices?
Options
- AMAC addresses on the entire broadcast domain are hidden from PEs, allowing for batter
- BIt is easier to troubleshoot.
- CLayer 3 equal-cost multipath can be used with redundant connections
- DLayer 2 requires a full-mesh network
How the community answered
(32 responses)- A72% (23)
- B3% (1)
- C19% (6)
- D6% (2)
Why each option
Using a router as the CE device in H-VPLS causes all customer MAC addresses to be hidden behind the router's single MAC address, preventing MAC table exhaustion on provider edge devices.
When a router acts as the CE device in H-VPLS, it terminates Layer 2 traffic and presents only its own MAC address to the provider edge (PE) router. All MAC addresses belonging to customer devices behind the CE router are invisible to the PE, preventing MAC table exhaustion on PE devices and allowing the VPLS service to scale across large multi-site deployments.
Using a router as a CE device introduces additional routing layers and is not inherently easier to troubleshoot than a switch-based CE configuration.
While Layer 3 ECMP is technically possible with a router CE, this is not the primary or defining advantage of using a router over a switch in H-VPLS design.
The full-mesh requirement is a scalability limitation of standard flat VPLS that H-VPLS was designed to solve - it describes the problem being addressed, not the specific advantage that a router CE provides.
Concept tested: H-VPLS router CE MAC address hiding for PE scalability
Source: https://www.cisco.com/c/en/us/td/docs/ios-xml/ios/mp_l2_vpns/configuration/xe-16/mp-l2-vpns-xe-16-book/mp-vpls-h-vpls.html
Topics
Community Discussion
No community discussion yet for this question.