352-001 · Question #538
A switched network is being designed to support a manufacturing factory. Due to cost constraints, fiber-based connectivity is not an option. Which design allows for a stable network when there is a ri
The correct answer is A. Design the network to include UDLD to detect unidirectional links and take them out of service.. In a factory with copper cabling subject to EMI from industrial equipment, UDLD detects links that have gone unidirectional and err-disables them before they can cause STP loops or traffic black holes.
Question
A switched network is being designed to support a manufacturing factory. Due to cost constraints, fiber-based connectivity is not an option. Which design allows for a stable network when there is a risk of interference from the manufacturing hardware in use on the factory floor?
Options
- ADesign the network to include UDLD to detect unidirectional links and take them out of service.
- BDesign the network to include Ether Channel bundles to prevent a single-link failure from taking
- CDesign the network to include loop guard to prevent a loop in the switched network when a link
- DDesign the network to include Backbone Fast on all devices to accelerate failure convergence
How the community answered
(23 responses)- A70% (16)
- B4% (1)
- C17% (4)
- D9% (2)
Why each option
In a factory with copper cabling subject to EMI from industrial equipment, UDLD detects links that have gone unidirectional and err-disables them before they can cause STP loops or traffic black holes.
Electromagnetic interference from manufacturing hardware can degrade copper cabling to the point where signal travels in only one direction, a condition STP cannot detect on its own and which causes forwarding loops or silent traffic drops. UDLD sends protocol messages in both directions and, when it no longer receives echoes back, identifies the link as unidirectional and places the port into err-disable state, removing the faulty link from service and preserving network stability without requiring fiber.
EtherChannel bundles tolerate a complete member-link failure by redistributing traffic across remaining members, but they have no mechanism to detect or handle the partial failure mode of a unidirectional link caused by EMI.
Loop Guard protects against STP topology errors when a non-designated port stops receiving BPDUs due to a unidirectional condition, but it only acts on the receiving switch and does not identify the physical root cause or disable the sending side of the affected link.
Backbone Fast shortens STP reconvergence after an indirect failure by bypassing the MaxAge timer, but it addresses topology change speed only and provides no protection against the unidirectional physical layer failures that interference introduces.
Concept tested: UDLD for unidirectional link detection in EMI-prone environments
Source: https://www.cisco.com/c/en/us/td/docs/switches/lan/catalyst6500/ios/12-2SX/configuration/guide/book/udld.html
Topics
Community Discussion
No community discussion yet for this question.