nerdexam
EC-Council

312-50V11 · Question #159

Bob received this text message on his mobile phone: "Hello, this is Scott Smelby from the Yahoo Bank. Kindly contact me for a vital transaction on: [email protected]". Which statement below is tru

The correct answer is A. This is scam as everybody can get a @yahoo address, not the Yahoo customer service. The @yahoo.com email address is a free consumer service anyone can register, meaning it provides zero proof of affiliation with any bank, making this a clear phishing attempt.

Social Engineering

Question

Bob received this text message on his mobile phone: "Hello, this is Scott Smelby from the Yahoo Bank. Kindly contact me for a vital transaction on: [email protected]". Which statement below is true?

Options

  • AThis is scam as everybody can get a @yahoo address, not the Yahoo customer service
  • BThis is scam because Bob does not know Scott.
  • CBob should write to [email protected] to verify the identity of Scott.
  • DThis is probably a legitimate message as it comes from a respectable organization.

How the community answered

(26 responses)
  • A
    88% (23)
  • C
    8% (2)
  • D
    4% (1)

Why each option

The @yahoo.com email address is a free consumer service anyone can register, meaning it provides zero proof of affiliation with any bank, making this a clear phishing attempt.

AThis is scam as everybody can get a @yahoo address, not the Yahoo customer serviceCorrect

Legitimate financial institutions communicate from official corporate domains (e.g., @yahoobank.com), not free consumer email providers like Yahoo Mail. Because any individual can create a @yahoo.com address in minutes, the use of [email protected] provides no authentication of organizational identity and is a classic social engineering red flag used in phishing attacks to impersonate trusted entities.

BThis is scam because Bob does not know Scott.

Not knowing the sender personally is not sufficient evidence of a scam, since legitimate first-contact messages from organizations are routinely sent to unknown recipients.

CBob should write to [email protected] to verify the identity of Scott.

Replying to the suspicious @yahoo.com address does not verify the sender's identity, as the attacker controls that address and any response would simply reach the attacker.

DThis is probably a legitimate message as it comes from a respectable organization.

The message is not legitimate - a respectable bank would never use a free consumer Yahoo Mail address for official customer communications involving financial transactions.

Concept tested: Phishing and social engineering via spoofed sender identity

Source: https://www.cisa.gov/news-events/news/avoiding-social-engineering-and-phishing-attacks

Topics

#phishing#smishing#social engineering#email spoofing

Community Discussion

No community discussion yet for this question.

Full 312-50V11 Practice