300-320 · Question #619
A network architect is designing a VPN solution for a client with these requirements multicast supported 80% of traffic is spoke to spoke minimal configuration. Which VPN type is the best choice?
The correct answer is C. DMVPN. DMVPN satisfies all three requirements - native multicast support via GRE tunnels, dynamic spoke-to-spoke tunnels (Phase 2/3) for direct traffic, and a hub-and-spoke configuration model that minimizes configuration.
Question
A network architect is designing a VPN solution for a client with these requirements multicast supported 80% of traffic is spoke to spoke minimal configuration. Which VPN type is the best choice?
Options
- AVTI
- BIPsec direct encapsulation
- CDMVPN
- DGRE over IPsec
How the community answered
(70 responses)- A4% (3)
- B9% (6)
- C84% (59)
- D3% (2)
Why each option
DMVPN satisfies all three requirements - native multicast support via GRE tunnels, dynamic spoke-to-spoke tunnels (Phase 2/3) for direct traffic, and a hub-and-spoke configuration model that minimizes configuration.
VTI (Virtual Tunnel Interface) creates point-to-point IPsec tunnels that do not natively support multicast and require a full mesh of tunnels for spoke-to-spoke traffic, increasing configuration complexity.
IPsec direct encapsulation does not support multicast traffic because IPsec is a unicast-only protocol and would require a separate GRE encapsulation layer to carry multicast.
DMVPN uses mGRE (multipoint GRE) tunnels that natively carry multicast traffic, NHRP to dynamically resolve spoke addresses enabling direct spoke-to-spoke sessions without hub involvement, and requires configuration only on the hub router with minimal per-spoke settings, satisfying all three design requirements simultaneously.
GRE over IPsec supports multicast via the GRE header, but achieving spoke-to-spoke communication requires either a full mesh of static tunnels or complex routing, resulting in significantly more configuration than DMVPN.
Concept tested: DMVPN multicast and spoke-to-spoke dynamic tunneling
Source: https://www.cisco.com/c/en/us/td/docs/ios-xml/ios/sec_conn_dmvpn/configuration/xe-16/sec-conn-dmvpn-xe-16-book/sec-conn-dmvpn-dmvpn.html
Topics
Community Discussion
No community discussion yet for this question.