SY0-501 · Question #385
An organization has several production-critical SCADA supervisory systems that cannot follow the normal 30- day patching policy. Which of the following BEST maximizes the protection of these systems…
The correct answer is A. Configure a firewall with deep packet inspection that restricts traffic to the systems. SCADA systems that cannot be patched require compensating controls; deep packet inspection (DPI) on a firewall provides the most robust protection by analyzing traffic content for malicious payloads at the network layer.
Question
An organization has several production-critical SCADA supervisory systems that cannot follow the normal 30- day patching policy. Which of the following BEST maximizes the protection of these systems from malicious software?
Options
- AConfigure a firewall with deep packet inspection that restricts traffic to the systems.
- BConfigure a separate zone for the systems and restrict access to known ports.
- CConfigure the systems to ensure only necessary applications are able to run.
- DConfigure the host firewall to ensure only the necessary applications have listening ports.
How the community answered
(63 responses)- A78% (49)
- B3% (2)
- C11% (7)
- D8% (5)
Why each option
SCADA systems that cannot be patched require compensating controls; deep packet inspection (DPI) on a firewall provides the most robust protection by analyzing traffic content for malicious payloads at the network layer.
A firewall with deep packet inspection (DPI) goes beyond simple port/protocol filtering by inspecting the actual content of packets for malware, exploits, and protocol anomalies. For unpatched SCADA systems, DPI acts as a virtual patching mechanism, identifying and blocking malicious traffic before it reaches the vulnerable system. This provides the strongest compensating control because it actively analyzes and blocks malicious software delivery attempts regardless of port or protocol.
Placing systems in a separate zone and restricting access to known ports is a basic network segmentation control that limits the attack surface but does not inspect traffic content for malware, leaving the systems vulnerable to attacks delivered over those permitted ports.
Application whitelisting (allowing only necessary applications to run) is a host-based control that prevents unauthorized software execution but does not directly protect against malicious software being delivered and potentially exploiting the allowed applications on an unpatched system.
Configuring the host firewall to restrict listening ports reduces exposure but only controls inbound connection points; it does not inspect the content of permitted traffic for malicious payloads and provides weaker protection than a network-level DPI firewall.
Concept tested: Compensating controls for unpatched SCADA systems using DPI
Source: https://www.cisa.gov/sites/default/files/recommended_practices/NCCIC_ICS-CERT_Defense_in_Depth_2016_S508C.pdf
Topics
Community Discussion
No community discussion yet for this question.