nerdexam
CompTIA

PT0-002 · Question #86

A penetration tester is reviewing the following SOW prior to engaging with a client: "Network diagrams, logical and physical asset inventory, and employees' names are to be treated as client…

The correct answer is C. Failing to share with the client critical vulnerabilities that exist within the client architecture to D. Seeking help with the engagement in underground hacker forums by sharing the client's public IP. Unethical behavior in a penetration test, particularly given an SOW, includes withholding critical findings from the client and disclosing client-identifying information to unauthorized third parties.

Engagement management

Question

A penetration tester is reviewing the following SOW prior to engaging with a client:

"Network diagrams, logical and physical asset inventory, and employees' names are to be treated as client confidential. Upon completion of the engagement, the penetration tester will submit findings to the client's Chief Information Security Officer (CISO) via encrypted protocols and subsequently dispose of all findings by erasing them in a secure manner." Based on the information in the SOW, which of the following behaviors would be considered unethical? (Choose two.)

Options

  • AUtilizing proprietary penetration-testing tools that are not available to the public or to the client for
  • BUtilizing public-key cryptography to ensure findings are delivered to the CISO upon completion of
  • CFailing to share with the client critical vulnerabilities that exist within the client architecture to
  • DSeeking help with the engagement in underground hacker forums by sharing the client's public IP
  • EUsing a software-based erase tool to wipe the client's findings from the penetration tester's laptop
  • FRetaining the SOW within the penetration tester's company for future use so the sales team can

How the community answered

(26 responses)
  • A
    4% (1)
  • B
    8% (2)
  • C
    77% (20)
  • F
    12% (3)

Why each option

Unethical behavior in a penetration test, particularly given an SOW, includes withholding critical findings from the client and disclosing client-identifying information to unauthorized third parties.

AUtilizing proprietary penetration-testing tools that are not available to the public or to the client for

Using proprietary tools is generally acceptable unless explicitly forbidden by the SOW or if it implies a lack of transparency that would hinder the client's ability to replicate findings.

BUtilizing public-key cryptography to ensure findings are delivered to the CISO upon completion of

Utilizing public-key cryptography to deliver findings securely aligns with the SOW's requirement to submit findings via "encrypted protocols" and is an ethical and responsible practice.

CFailing to share with the client critical vulnerabilities that exist within the client architecture toCorrect

Failing to share critical vulnerabilities with the client is unethical because the core purpose of a penetration test is to identify and report such weaknesses to improve the client's security posture. Withholding this information defeats the purpose of the engagement.

DSeeking help with the engagement in underground hacker forums by sharing the client's public IPCorrect

Sharing the client's public IP address in underground hacker forums, even while seeking help, constitutes a breach of confidentiality and trust, as it exposes the client's identity and potential targets to malicious actors, which violates the SOW's confidentiality clause regarding network diagrams and asset inventory.

EUsing a software-based erase tool to wipe the client's findings from the penetration tester's laptop

Using a software-based erase tool to wipe findings is a secure manner of disposal and aligns with the SOW's requirement to "dispose of all findings by erasing them in a secure manner."

FRetaining the SOW within the penetration tester's company for future use so the sales team can

Retaining the SOW itself for internal company use (e.g., sales, project management) is standard business practice and does not typically violate the confidentiality of the client's operational data defined in the SOW.

Concept tested: Penetration testing ethics, SOW compliance

Source: null

Topics

#Confidentiality#Ethical hacking#SOW compliance#Reporting obligations

Community Discussion

No community discussion yet for this question.

Full PT0-002 Practice