PT0-001 · Question #42
During testing, a critical vulnerability is discovered on a client's core server. Which of the following should be the NEXT action?
The correct answer is C. Promptly alert the client with details of the finding. Professional penetration testing rules of engagement require immediate escalation of critical findings to the client so they can manage the risk before the engagement window closes.
Question
During testing, a critical vulnerability is discovered on a client's core server. Which of the following should be the NEXT action?
Options
- ADisable the network port of the affected service.
- BComplete all findings, and then submit them to the client.
- CPromptly alert the client with details of the finding.
- DTake the target offline so it cannot be exploited by an attacker.
How the community answered
(26 responses)- A4% (1)
- C92% (24)
- D4% (1)
Why each option
Professional penetration testing rules of engagement require immediate escalation of critical findings to the client so they can manage the risk before the engagement window closes.
Disabling network ports or services on client infrastructure without explicit prior authorization exceeds the agreed scope of the penetration test and constitutes unauthorized modification of production systems.
Completing all findings before reporting delays the client's awareness of a critical risk that may require immediate emergency remediation, violating responsible disclosure expectations built into most engagement contracts.
Standard penetration testing ethics and rules of engagement require that critical vulnerabilities be reported to the client immediately upon discovery, because the finding represents an active and severe threat to the target environment. Waiting until all testing is complete could allow the vulnerability to be exploited by a real threat actor during the remaining engagement window. Promptly alerting the client with technical details enables them to make an informed decision about emergency remediation or risk acceptance.
Taking a target system offline without client authorization disrupts business operations and falls outside the tester's approved scope, regardless of the severity of the vulnerability found.
Concept tested: Responsible disclosure and escalation during penetration testing engagements
Source: http://www.pentest-standard.org/index.php/Reporting
Topics
Community Discussion
No community discussion yet for this question.