CRISC · Question #628
Senior management has requested a risk practitioner's guidance on whether a new technical control requested by a business unit is worth the investment. Which of the following should be the MOST…
The correct answer is B. The effectiveness of the control at reducing residual risk levels. When evaluating a new control, the most important consideration is its effectiveness in reducing residual risk, as this directly quantifies the security benefit derived from the investment.
Question
Senior management has requested a risk practitioner's guidance on whether a new technical control requested by a business unit is worth the investment. Which of the following should be the MOST important consideration before providing input?
Options
- AThe cost of the control relative to the value of risk mitigation
- BThe effectiveness of the control at reducing residual risk levels
- CThe likelihood of a successful attack based on current risk
- Dassessments
- EThe availabilitv of budgeted funds for risk mitigationMitination
How the community answered
(44 responses)- A5% (2)
- B57% (25)
- C14% (6)
- D2% (1)
- E23% (10)
Why each option
When evaluating a new control, the most important consideration is its effectiveness in reducing residual risk, as this directly quantifies the security benefit derived from the investment.
While cost-benefit analysis is crucial, it cannot be fully performed without first understanding the *effectiveness* of the control (the 'benefit' side of the equation).
The core purpose of any control investment is to reduce risk. Therefore, the most important consideration is how effectively the proposed control reduces the existing residual risk to an acceptable level, demonstrating its value in achieving security objectives. Without knowing its effectiveness, assessing its 'worth' is impossible.
The likelihood of an attack is part of the initial risk assessment, but the question is about evaluating a *new control*, so the control's impact on reducing that risk (its effectiveness) is paramount.
Availability of budgeted funds is an organizational constraint, not the primary technical consideration for assessing the *worth* or effectiveness of a control.
Concept tested: Control effectiveness evaluation
Topics
Community Discussion
No community discussion yet for this question.