nerdexam
ASQ

CRE · Question #302

A "fail-safe" requirement means:

The correct answer is B. The system will fall in a safe state. Fail-safe means that when a system fails, it defaults to a safe condition rather than a dangerous one - this is exactly what B captures. A railway signal that defaults to "red" (stop) when the electronics fail is a classic example: the failure itself produces a safe outcome…

Reliability in Design and Development

Question

A "fail-safe" requirement means:

Options

  • AThe system is safe from failure.
  • BThe system will fall in a safe state.
  • CThe system has safety devices.
  • DThe safety systems cannot fail.

How the community answered

(34 responses)
  • A
    6% (2)
  • B
    79% (27)
  • C
    12% (4)
  • D
    3% (1)

Explanation

Fail-safe means that when a system fails, it defaults to a safe condition rather than a dangerous one - this is exactly what B captures. A railway signal that defaults to "red" (stop) when the electronics fail is a classic example: the failure itself produces a safe outcome.

Why the distractors are wrong:

  • A is wrong because "fail-safe" makes no promise that failure won't occur - it only controls what happens when it does.
  • C is wrong because having safety devices is a broader design strategy; it doesn't specifically mean the failure mode is safe.
  • D is wrong because no system can guarantee safety systems never fail - that would be an impossible standard. Fail-safe is about failure behavior, not failure prevention.

Memory tip: Break the phrase apart - "fail" then "safe." The system fails, and the result is safe. If the phrase meant preventing failure (A or D), it would be called "fail-proof" or "fail-prevent."

Topics

#fail-safe design#safe failure state#system safety#design requirements

Community Discussion

No community discussion yet for this question.

Full CRE Practice