CISM · Question #741
The security team is developing a business case to submit to the IT steering committee for the implementation of a fraud detection system. Including which of the following would be MOST helpful to…
The correct answer is B. Return on investment (ROI). ROI (Return on Investment) is the most helpful metric for a steering committee making a funding decision because it directly quantifies the financial benefit of the investment relative to its cost - translating security value into business language that decision-makers use to…
Question
The security team is developing a business case to submit to the IT steering committee for the implementation of a fraud detection system. Including which of the following would be MOST helpful to the committee in reaching a decision?
Options
- ATotal cost of ownership (TCO)
- BReturn on investment (ROI)
- CAnnual loss expectancy (ALE)
- DStrengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats (SWOT)
How the community answered
(24 responses)- A4% (1)
- B75% (18)
- C8% (2)
- D13% (3)
Explanation
ROI (Return on Investment) is the most helpful metric for a steering committee making a funding decision because it directly quantifies the financial benefit of the investment relative to its cost - translating security value into business language that decision-makers use to prioritize spending.
- TCO (A) only covers costs without showing the benefit side; it tells you what you'll spend but not what you'll gain, making it insufficient for justifying approval on its own.
- ALE (C) estimates expected annual losses from a threat and is useful for risk analysis, but it's an input to the business case, not the decision-making metric itself - it feeds into the ROI calculation.
- SWOT (D) is a strategic planning framework that provides qualitative context but doesn't give a committee a clear financial basis for approving or rejecting an investment.
Memory tip: Think of it this way - a steering committee is essentially asking "Is this worth our money?" Only ROI directly answers that question with a ratio of value gained versus cost. When a question involves justifying a new system to leadership, ROI is almost always the answer.
Topics
Community Discussion
No community discussion yet for this question.