CISA · Question #5
Which of the following should an IS auditor be MOST concerned with during a post- implementation review?
The correct answer is A. The system does not have a maintenance plan.. During a post-implementation review, an IS auditor should be most concerned if the system lacks a maintenance plan, as this impacts its long-term viability, security, and operational integrity.
Question
Which of the following should an IS auditor be MOST concerned with during a post- implementation review?
Options
- AThe system does not have a maintenance plan.
- BThe system contains several minor defects.
- CThe system deployment was delayed by three weeks.
- DThe system was over budget by 15%.
How the community answered
(16 responses)- A63% (10)
- B13% (2)
- C6% (1)
- D19% (3)
Why each option
During a post-implementation review, an IS auditor should be most concerned if the system lacks a maintenance plan, as this impacts its long-term viability, security, and operational integrity.
A robust maintenance plan ensures the system remains secure, performs optimally, and continues to meet business needs over its lifecycle. The absence of such a plan indicates a significant control weakness that could lead to system degradation, security vulnerabilities, or obsolescence, which is a major concern for an IS auditor focusing on ongoing operational controls and risk.
Several minor defects, while undesirable, are common and can be addressed through standard maintenance; their presence is less critical than the lack of a plan for ongoing system health.
A deployment delay is a project management issue that occurred in the past; while it might point to process inefficiencies, it is less of an ongoing control concern for the auditor than the lack of a maintenance plan.
Being over budget is also a past project management issue; while it impacts financial performance, it doesn't directly compromise the system's operational control environment or long-term sustainability as much as the absence of a maintenance plan.
Concept tested: Post-implementation audit concerns, system lifecycle
Source: https://www.isaca.org/resources/isaca-journal/2007/volume-4/a-post-implementation-review-process-for-it-projects
Topics
Community Discussion
No community discussion yet for this question.