352-001 · Question #78
What are three drawbacks of VPLS? (Choose three.)
The correct answer is A. Direct-attached VPLS requires a full mesh of pseudowires. C. MAC scalability may be problematic, since customer MACs will be visible on the service provider network. D. VPLS requires a large amount of multicast and broadcast replication.. VPLS has three primary drawbacks: full-mesh pseudowire requirements, MAC address scalability issues on the SP network, and high BUM (broadcast/unknown/multicast) replication overhead.
Question
What are three drawbacks of VPLS? (Choose three.)
Options
- ADirect-attached VPLS requires a full mesh of pseudowires.
- BVPLS cannot support IP bridging (as defined in the VPLS standard).
- CMAC scalability may be problematic, since customer MACs will be visible on the service provider network.
- DVPLS requires a large amount of multicast and broadcast replication.
How the community answered
(26 responses)- A77% (20)
- B23% (6)
Why each option
VPLS has three primary drawbacks: full-mesh pseudowire requirements, MAC address scalability issues on the SP network, and high BUM (broadcast/unknown/multicast) replication overhead.
In direct-attached (flat) VPLS without H-VPLS hierarchy, every PE router must maintain a pseudowire to every other PE in the same VPLS instance, resulting in O(n^2) pseudowire scaling that becomes unmanageable in large deployments.
VPLS is specifically designed to support Layer 2 IP bridging by emulating an Ethernet LAN segment across an MPLS network, so the inability to support IP bridging is not a valid drawback.
Because VPLS emulates an Ethernet bridge, PE routers must learn and store all customer MAC addresses, exposing customer MAC tables to the service provider infrastructure and creating MAC table scale problems as customer counts grow.
VPLS uses ingress replication (flooding) to handle broadcast, unknown-unicast, and multicast traffic, meaning each PE must replicate and forward BUM frames across all pseudowires in the VPLS instance, consuming significant bandwidth and CPU.
Concept tested: VPLS scalability and architectural drawbacks
Source: https://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc4664
Topics
Community Discussion
No community discussion yet for this question.