352-001 · Question #70
A company has these requirements for access to their wireless and wired corporate LANs using 802.1x: - Client devices that are corporate assets and have been joined to the Active Directory domain…
The correct answer is B. Extensible Authentication Protocol-Transport Layer Security with machine authentication. EAP-TLS with machine authentication uses computer certificates issued to domain-joined devices, ensuring only corporate assets can authenticate and providing mutual authentication.
Question
A company has these requirements for access to their wireless and wired corporate LANs using 802.1x:
- Client devices that are corporate assets and have been joined to the Active Directory domain are
allowed access.
- Personal devices must not be allowed access.
- Clients and access servers must be mutually authenticated.
Which solution meets these requirements?
Options
- AProtected Extensible Authentication Protocol/Microsoft Challenge Handshake Authentication Protocol
- BExtensible Authentication Protocol-Transport Layer Security with machine authentication
- CExtensible Authentication Protocol-Transport Layer Security with user authentication
- DProtected Extensible Authentication Protocol/Microsoft Challenge Handshake Authentication Protocol
How the community answered
(46 responses)- A15% (7)
- B74% (34)
- C7% (3)
- D4% (2)
Why each option
EAP-TLS with machine authentication uses computer certificates issued to domain-joined devices, ensuring only corporate assets can authenticate and providing mutual authentication.
PEAP/MSCHAPv2 authenticates using user credentials (username and password), which a personal device owner could supply, so it cannot restrict access to corporate-asset machines.
EAP-TLS with machine authentication requires a valid X.509 certificate installed on the client machine, which Active Directory domain-joined corporate devices receive via Group Policy - personal devices lack these certificates and are denied access. The TLS handshake also authenticates the RADIUS server to the client, satisfying the mutual authentication requirement.
EAP-TLS with user authentication relies on user certificates rather than machine certificates, meaning a user could authenticate from a personal device if the user certificate is present or portable.
PEAP/MSCHAPv2 (same as choice A) relies on user credentials and cannot enforce that only domain-joined corporate machines gain access.
Concept tested: EAP-TLS machine authentication for device-based 802.1x access control
Source: https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/windows-server/networking/technologies/nps/nps-top
Topics
Community Discussion
No community discussion yet for this question.