312-50V9 · Question #62
What is the main advantage that a network-based IDS/IPS system has over a host-based solution?
The correct answer is A. They do not use host system resources. A network-based IDS/IPS is a dedicated appliance that monitors traffic without running on protected hosts, leaving their CPU and memory fully available.
Question
What is the main advantage that a network-based IDS/IPS system has over a host-based solution?
Options
- AThey do not use host system resources.
- BThey are placed at the boundary, allowing them to inspect all traffic.
- CThey are easier to install and configure.
- DThey will not interfere with user interfaces.
How the community answered
(32 responses)- A94% (30)
- B3% (1)
- C3% (1)
Why each option
A network-based IDS/IPS is a dedicated appliance that monitors traffic without running on protected hosts, leaving their CPU and memory fully available.
A network-based IDS/IPS operates as a standalone sensor on the network, passively inspecting traffic via a tap or SPAN port without any agent installed on the monitored endpoints. Because it runs on its own dedicated hardware, it consumes none of the CPU, memory, disk I/O, or network stack resources of the host systems it protects. This resource independence is the primary operational advantage over host-based solutions, which must share system resources with production applications.
While NIDS sensors are often placed at network boundaries, this placement is a deployment choice, not an inherent advantage; host-based IDS cannot inspect boundary-level traffic, but boundary placement alone is not identified as the main advantage over HIDS.
Network-based IDS/IPS systems require more complex setup involving network taps, SPAN port configuration, or inline placement, making them generally harder to install and configure than a host-based agent.
Both NIDS and HIDS can be designed to operate transparently with minimal impact on user-facing interfaces; this is not a distinguishing advantage that is specific to the network-based approach.
Concept tested: Network-based vs host-based IDS/IPS advantages
Source: https://www.cisco.com/c/en/us/td/docs/security/ips/7-0/configuration/guide/idm/idm70guide/overview.html
Topics
Community Discussion
No community discussion yet for this question.