nerdexam
EC-Council

312-50V9 · Question #183

Your company performs penetration tests and security assessments for small and medium-sized business in the local area. During a routine security assessment, you discover information that suggests…

The correct answer is A. Immediately stop work and contact the proper legal authorities. Discovering evidence of serious crimes such as human trafficking during a security assessment creates an immediate legal and ethical duty to halt work and contact law enforcement.

Introduction to Ethical Hacking

Question

Your company performs penetration tests and security assessments for small and medium-sized business in the local area. During a routine security assessment, you discover information that suggests your client is involved with human trafficking. What should you do?

Options

  • AImmediately stop work and contact the proper legal authorities.
  • BCopy the data to removable media and keep it in case you need it.
  • CConfront the client in a respectful manner and ask her about the data.
  • DIgnore the data and continue the assessment until completed as agreed.

How the community answered

(25 responses)
  • A
    88% (22)
  • C
    4% (1)
  • D
    8% (2)

Why each option

Discovering evidence of serious crimes such as human trafficking during a security assessment creates an immediate legal and ethical duty to halt work and contact law enforcement.

AImmediately stop work and contact the proper legal authorities.Correct

Security professionals who uncover evidence of serious crimes are legally and ethically obligated to report it to the appropriate authorities without delay. Continuing the assessment could be construed as complicity, and the professional duty of care to society supersedes the contractual obligation to the client in cases involving criminal activity.

BCopy the data to removable media and keep it in case you need it.

Copying the data to removable media risks tainting the evidentiary chain of custody and could constitute evidence tampering, complicating any subsequent prosecution.

CConfront the client in a respectful manner and ask her about the data.

Confronting the client directly is dangerous, could allow the client to destroy evidence, and is not the role of a security assessor.

DIgnore the data and continue the assessment until completed as agreed.

Ignoring criminal activity and completing the engagement makes the assessor potentially complicit in ongoing crimes and exposes them to serious legal liability.

Concept tested: Ethical duty to report crimes discovered during assessments

Topics

#ethics#legal obligations#incident reporting#professional conduct

Community Discussion

No community discussion yet for this question.

Full 312-50V9 Practice