312-50V11 · Question #620
While performing ping scans into a target network you get a frantic call from the organization's security team. They report that they are under a denial of service attack. When you stop your scan, the
The correct answer is B. Do not scan the broadcast IP.. Pinging a broadcast address generates the same ICMP flood pattern as a Smurf attack, so excluding broadcast IPs from the scan stops the IDS from firing.
Question
While performing ping scans into a target network you get a frantic call from the organization's security team. They report that they are under a denial of service attack. When you stop your scan, the smurf attack event stops showing up on the organization's IDS monitor. How can you modify your scan to prevent triggering this event in the IDS?
Options
- AScan more slowly.
- BDo not scan the broadcast IP.
- CSpoof the source IP address.
- DOnly scan the Windows systems.
How the community answered
(31 responses)- A29% (9)
- B48% (15)
- C10% (3)
- D13% (4)
Why each option
Pinging a broadcast address generates the same ICMP flood pattern as a Smurf attack, so excluding broadcast IPs from the scan stops the IDS from firing.
Scanning more slowly reduces packet volume but does not change the broadcast ICMP pattern that triggers the Smurf attack IDS signature.
A Smurf attack sends ICMP echo requests to a network broadcast address with a spoofed source IP, causing every host on the segment to reply to the victim and creating a flood. When a ping scan includes the broadcast address, it produces the same ICMP-to-broadcast signature that Smurf detection rules watch for. Removing the broadcast IP from the scan target list eliminates this pattern entirely and prevents the false-positive IDS alert.
Spoofing the source IP makes your scan more closely resemble an actual Smurf attack, which would escalate the IDS alert rather than suppress it.
Restricting scans to Windows systems is unrelated to the broadcast address behavior that triggers the Smurf detection rule.
Concept tested: Smurf attack IDS evasion by avoiding broadcast IP
Source: https://www.cisco.com/c/en/us/about/security-center/smurf.html
Topics
Community Discussion
No community discussion yet for this question.