312-50V10 · Question #620
While performing ping scans into a target network you get a frantic call from the organization's security team. They report that they are under a denial of service attack. When you stop your scan, the
The correct answer is B. Do not scan the broadcast IP.. Sending ICMP ping requests to a subnet's broadcast address causes all hosts to reply simultaneously, which mirrors the pattern of a smurf attack and triggers IDS alerts.
Question
While performing ping scans into a target network you get a frantic call from the organization's security team. They report that they are under a denial of service attack. When you stop your scan, the smurf attack event stops showing up on the organization's IDS monitor. How can you modify your scan to prevent triggering this event in the IDS?
Options
- AScan more slowly.
- BDo not scan the broadcast IP.
- CSpoof the source IP address.
- DOnly scan the Windows systems.
How the community answered
(55 responses)- A18% (10)
- B69% (38)
- C4% (2)
- D9% (5)
Why each option
Sending ICMP ping requests to a subnet's broadcast address causes all hosts to reply simultaneously, which mirrors the pattern of a smurf attack and triggers IDS alerts.
Scanning more slowly reduces overall traffic volume but does not eliminate the broadcast reply amplification that triggers the smurf attack IDS signature.
A smurf attack works by sending ICMP echo requests to a broadcast address so that every host on the subnet replies, flooding the apparent source. When a ping scan includes the broadcast IP, it generates the same mass-reply traffic pattern that IDS signatures detect as a smurf attack. Excluding the broadcast IP from the scan eliminates this pattern while still allowing the rest of the network to be scanned.
Spoofing the source IP would redirect all the broadcast replies to the spoofed address, making the attack worse and not preventing the IDS alert.
Restricting scans to Windows systems does not prevent targeting the broadcast IP, which is the root cause of the smurf-like event.
Concept tested: Smurf attack triggered by broadcast IP ping scan
Source: https://www.cisa.gov/sites/default/files/publications/understanding-and-preventing-smurf-attacks_508c.pdf
Topics
Community Discussion
No community discussion yet for this question.