156-215.80 · Question #91
When attempting to start a VPN tunnel, in the logs the error 'no proposal chosen' is seen numerous times. No other VPN-related log entries are present. Which phase of the VPN negotiations has failed?
The correct answer is D. IKE Phase 2. The 'no proposal chosen' error indicates IKE Phase 2 (Quick Mode) failed because the two VPN peers could not agree on a matching IPSec transform set.
Question
When attempting to start a VPN tunnel, in the logs the error 'no proposal chosen' is seen numerous times. No other VPN-related log entries are present. Which phase of the VPN negotiations has failed?
Options
- AIKE Phase 1
- BIPSEC Phase 2
- CIPSEC Phase 1
- DIKE Phase 2
How the community answered
(35 responses)- A17% (6)
- B6% (2)
- C9% (3)
- D69% (24)
Why each option
The 'no proposal chosen' error indicates IKE Phase 2 (Quick Mode) failed because the two VPN peers could not agree on a matching IPSec transform set.
IKE Phase 1 failures produce errors related to ISAKMP SA negotiation, authentication mismatches, or pre-shared key failures - not 'no proposal chosen'.
'IPSec Phase 2' is not a standard term; the correct designation is IKE Phase 2, which handles IPSec SA negotiation.
'IPSec Phase 1' is not a standard term; the correct designation is IKE Phase 1, which establishes the ISAKMP SA.
IKE Phase 2 (Quick Mode) is where peers negotiate IPSec Security Associations, including encryption algorithm, integrity hash, and lifetime values. The 'no proposal chosen' error means the responder found no matching transform set among those offered by the initiator, causing Phase 2 to fail. The absence of any other log entries implies Phase 1 completed successfully, isolating the failure to Phase 2.
Concept tested: IKE Phase 2 Quick Mode negotiation failure diagnosis
Source: https://www.cisco.com/c/en/us/support/docs/security-vpn/ipsec-negotiation-ike-protocols/5409-ipsec-debug-00.html
Topics
Community Discussion
No community discussion yet for this question.